No Fresh Opportunity to Deposit Pre-emption Money in a Suit That Stands Disposed of for Failure to Deposit Within 30 Days: High Court (Pre-emption)

Supreme Court of Bangladesh 
The High Court has observed that where the required money for pre-emption or Haq-e-Shufa is not deposited within the stipulated period and the suit consequently stands disposed of, the same court cannot subsequently permit the deposit of the money afresh.

In the judgment delivered on 3 September 2026 by Mr. Justice Abdur Rahman in Khandakar Istiak Ahmed and Others v. Alhaz Md. Abdul Aziz Dhali and Others, Civil Revision No. 1325 of 2026, the Court upheld the order passed by the learned Senior District Judge, Natore, and discharged the Rule. The judgment was published on the website of the Supreme Court on 1 October 2026.

Background of the Case:

An Other Class (Shufa) Suit No. 36 of 2013 was instituted before the Court of the learned Joint District Judge, First Court, Natore, seeking enforcement of a right of pre-emption (Haq-e-Shufa) under Muslim Law.

On 31 October 2017, upon an application filed by Defendant Nos. 1 and 2, the learned trial Court decreed the suit on admission. At the same time, the plaintiff was directed to deposit Tk. 52,50,000, comprising the consideration money and compensation, in favour of Defendant Nos. 1 and 2 within 30 days. The Court further directed that, in default of such deposit within the stipulated period, the suit would stand dismissed.

Instead of depositing the money within the stipulated period, the plaintiff preferred First Appeal No. 23 of 2018 before the High Court Division and obtained a stay of the operation of the decree on 29 January 2018. Subsequently, the appeal was dismissed for non-prosecution on 7 October 2024, and the earlier order of stay was vacated.

Thereafter, on 30 April 2025, the plaintiff again filed an application seeking permission to deposit Tk. 52,50,000. The trial Court allowed the application on 27 May 2025, and the plaintiff subsequently submitted the challan evidencing the deposit on 7 July 2025.

The defendants challenged the said order by filing Civil Revision No. 29 of 2025. The learned Senior District Judge, Natore, allowed the revision and set aside the order of the trial Court on 1 April 2026. Being aggrieved, the plaintiff approached the High Court Division by filing the present revisional application.

Observations of the High Court:

The High Court observed that the decree dated 31 October 2017 expressly required the plaintiff to deposit the stipulated amount within 30 days. The plaintiff failed to do so within the prescribed period and subsequently pursued an appeal, which was eventually dismissed. In such circumstances, the trial Court could not subsequently reopen the matter and permit a fresh deposit of the same amount.

The Court held that the trial Court had become functus officio in respect of the matter.

Explaining the doctrine of functus officio, the Court observed that once a court has finally performed its judicial function and reached a final decision on a particular matter, it ordinarily has no further authority to reconsider or alter that decision unless such power is specifically conferred by law. The principle protects the finality of judicial decisions.

Principles of Haq-e-Shufa:

The judgment also discusses the fundamental principles governing the right of pre-emption under Muslim Law. The Court noted that enforcement of the right generally involves three talabs or demands:

Talab-i-Mowasibat — an immediate demand upon receiving information of the sale;

Talab-i-Ishhad — confirmation of the claim in the manner prescribed by law, traditionally in the presence of witnesses; and

Talab-i-Tamlik/Talab-i-Khusumat — institution of legal proceedings to establish and enforce the right of pre-emption.

The judgment further notes that the consideration mentioned in the relevant sale deed was Tk. 50,00,000, whereas the plaintiff sought, by way of amendment, to substitute the amount with Tk. 20,00,000.

The Court observed that the proposed amendment was not merely a formal or clerical correction. Rather, it sought to alter a material particular of the transaction upon which the pre-emption claim was founded. Accordingly, the Court found no sufficient legal basis for allowing such an amendment under Order VI, Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. The trial Court was therefore justified in rejecting the amendment application and decreeing the suit on admission.

Final Decision:

The High Court found that the learned Senior District Judge, Natore, had rightly set aside the trial Court's order dated 27 May 2025, which had permitted the plaintiff to deposit the consideration money in the matter.

Accordingly, the Rule in Civil Revision No. 1325 of 2026 was discharged, and the judgment and order dated 1 April 2026 passed by the learned Senior District Judge, Natore, were affirmed and upheld. There was no order as to costs.

However, the High Court permitted the plaintiff-petitioners to withdraw the Tk. 52,50,000 that had been deposited pursuant to the trial Court's order dated 27 May 2025. The trial Court was directed to ensure that the petitioners receive the entire deposited amount without harassment or delay. Any stay order previously granted by the High Court was also recalled and vacated.


BD Law Post/Masum

Next Post Previous Post
No Comment
Add Comment
comment url