Hostile Witness: Concept and Evidentiary Value under the Law of Bangladesh
1. Introduction
A hostile witness is generally understood as a witness called by a party to support its case but who, during the course of giving evidence, adopts an adverse position, gives testimony contrary to the case of the party calling him, or supports the case of the opposite party.
Although the expression “hostile witness” is not expressly defined or specifically used in the Evidence Act, 1872, the concept is recognized under Section 154 of the Act. This provision enables the Court, in its discretion, to permit a party to cross-examine its own witness.
The doctrine is important because a party cannot always anticipate how a witness will testify at trial. A witness may change his version, deny facts previously stated, or give evidence favourable to the opposite side. Section 154 provides a mechanism for dealing with such circumstances.
2. Statutory Basis: Section 154 of the Evidence Act, 1872
The principal statutory provision relating to a hostile witness is Section 154 of the Evidence Act, 1872.
The section empowers the Court to permit the party who has called a witness to put questions to that witness which might be put to him in cross-examination by the adverse party.
Thus, where a witness called by a party becomes adverse during his testimony, the Court may, upon application and in the exercise of its discretion, allow the calling party to cross-examine that witness.
It is important to note that the Court's permission is essential. A party does not have an absolute right to cross-examine its own witness merely because the witness has given an unexpected or unfavourable answer.
3. When May a Witness Be Treated as Hostile?
A witness may be treated as hostile where his conduct or testimony indicates that he has departed from the position expected by the party calling him.
Circumstances may include:
- giving evidence contrary to the case of the party who called the witness;
- materially departing from an earlier statement;
- denying facts that the party expected the witness to establish;
- supporting the case of the opposite party;
- deliberately withholding material facts; or
- displaying an adverse or antagonistic attitude during testimony.
However, every contradiction, inconsistency, or unfavourable statement does not automatically make a witness hostile. The Court must consider the nature and circumstances of the evidence before exercising its discretion under Section 154.
4. Procedure for Dealing with a Hostile Witness
The procedure may generally be summarized as follows:
Step 1: Calling the Witness
A party calls a witness before the Court with the expectation that the witness will give evidence supporting its case.
Step 2: Adverse Testimony
During examination-in-chief, the witness gives evidence which is inconsistent with, contrary to, or damaging to the case of the party calling him.
Step 3: Application to the Court
The party may request the Court for permission to cross-examine its own witness under Section 154.
Step 4: Exercise of Judicial Discretion
The Court considers the conduct and testimony of the witness and decides whether permission should be granted.
Step 5: Cross-Examination
If permission is granted, the party calling the witness may put questions to him in the manner permitted during cross-examination, including leading questions where appropriate.
Step 6: Appreciation of Evidence
The Court thereafter considers the entire testimony of the witness together with the other evidence on record and determines which portions, if any, are worthy of reliance.
5. Evidentiary Value of a Hostile Witness
One of the most important principles concerning hostile witnesses is that the entire testimony of a hostile witness is not automatically rejected or erased from the record.
The declaration of a witness as hostile does not make every statement made by that witness legally worthless.
The Court is required to examine the evidence carefully and determine which portions are:
- credible;
- consistent;
- supported by other evidence; and
- worthy of judicial reliance.
Accordingly, a Court may accept one portion of a hostile witness's testimony while rejecting another portion.
Therefore, the correct principle is:
The evidence of a hostile witness is not wholly effaced merely because the witness has been declared hostile.
6. Credible Portion of Hostile Evidence May Be Relied Upon
A hostile witness may give both favourable and unfavourable evidence during the same trial.
The fact that the witness has been permitted to be cross-examined by the party calling him does not mean that the Court must disregard everything he has said.
If a particular part of the testimony appears to be truthful and is supported by other reliable evidence, the Court may rely upon that portion.
Conversely, where a particular statement is found to be unreliable, inconsistent, or unsupported by the evidence on record, the Court may reject it.
Thus, the evidence of a hostile witness is subject to careful judicial appreciation rather than automatic rejection.
7. Importance of Corroboration
The credibility of relevant portions of a hostile witness's testimony may be assessed in light of other evidence available on the record.
Such evidence may include:
- medical evidence;
- documentary evidence;
- forensic or physical evidence;
- circumstantial evidence;
- other independent witnesses; and
- other legally admissible evidence.
Where a portion of the hostile witness's testimony is corroborated by reliable and independent evidence, the Court may consider that portion worthy of acceptance.
Therefore, the turning hostile of a material witness does not, by itself, necessarily bring the entire case to an end. The Court must examine the totality of the evidence.
8. Relevant Case Law
Abu Taher v. The State, 14 BLT (HCD) 68
In Abu Taher v. The State, 14 BLT (HCD) 68, the issue concerning hostile witnesses was considered in the context of the overall evidentiary circumstances of the case.
The case illustrates the principle that even where important witnesses become hostile, a conviction may still be sustained where the remaining evidence provides a reliable evidentiary foundation.
The Court's assessment may include medical evidence, circumstantial evidence, primary evidence, and other reliable materials available on the record.
Principle: The evidence of hostile witnesses should be considered together with the other evidence, rather than being automatically discarded merely because the witnesses have turned hostile.
Babul v. The State, 57 DLR 158
In Babul v. The State, 57 DLR 158, the High Court Division considered the evidentiary effect of a prosecution witness being declared hostile.
The decision recognizes that the evidence of a hostile witness is not completely effaced from the record merely because the witness has been declared hostile.
Where a portion of the testimony is found to be credible and acceptable, that portion may be relied upon by the Court.
Principle: Declaring a witness hostile does not make his entire evidence inadmissible or worthless; the credible portion may still be acted upon.
9. Hostile Witness and Cross-Examination
Section 154 is significant because it allows a party, with the permission of the Court, to cross-examine its own witness.
Ordinarily, a party calls a witness to establish its case. However, where the witness gives evidence adverse to that party, the Court may permit the party to question the witness in the manner of cross-examination.
This provision serves an important purpose: it enables the Court to ascertain the truth despite an unexpected change in the testimony of a witness.
However, the grant of permission to cross-examine a witness does not itself determine the credibility of the witness. The credibility and evidentiary value of the testimony remain matters for judicial appreciation.
10. Hostile Witness Does Not Mean an Entirely Unreliable Witness
A significant misconception is that once a witness is declared hostile, he becomes a completely unreliable witness.
That is not the correct approach.
A witness may be hostile in relation to certain portions of his testimony while still giving evidence that the Court finds reliable on other matters.
The Court therefore has to separate the trustworthy portions from the untrustworthy portions and assess them in the context of the entire case.
In simple terms:
Hostility affects the manner in which the evidence is appreciated; it does not automatically destroy the evidentiary value of the entire testimony.
11. Distinction Between Hostile Witness and Unreliable Witness
The concepts of hostility and unreliability should not be treated as identical.
A witness may be declared hostile because he has adopted a position adverse to the party who called him. Nevertheless, some portions of his testimony may remain reliable.
On the other hand, a witness may not be formally declared hostile but may still give evidence that the Court ultimately finds unreliable.
Therefore, the question whether a witness is hostile and the question whether a particular part of his evidence is reliable are separate matters.
12. Key Legal Principles
The law relating to hostile witnesses in Bangladesh may be summarized as follows:
- The expression “hostile witness” is not expressly defined in the Evidence Act, 1872.
- Section 154 provides the statutory basis for cross-examining one's own witness.
- Permission to cross-examine one's own witness rests with the discretion of the Court.
- A witness does not automatically become hostile merely because he gives an unfavourable answer.
- A hostile witness's entire testimony is not automatically erased or rejected.
- The Court may accept the credible portion and reject the unreliable portion of the testimony.
- Corroboration by independent and reliable evidence may strengthen the credibility of a relevant portion of hostile testimony.
- The fact that a prosecution witness has turned hostile does not, by itself, necessarily destroy the prosecution case.
- The evidence must be appreciated as a whole and in light of the other evidence on record.
13. Conclusion
The doctrine of the hostile witness occupies an important position in the law of evidence in Bangladesh. Although the term itself is not expressly defined in the Evidence Act, 1872, Section 154 provides the legal mechanism through which a party may, with the Court's permission, cross-examine its own witness.
The most important principle is that hostility does not automatically render the entire testimony of a witness worthless. The Court must carefully evaluate the evidence and may rely upon those portions which are found to be credible, trustworthy, and consistent with other evidence on record.
Accordingly, the legal position may be stated in the following terms:
A witness being declared hostile does not completely efface his evidence from the record. The Court may rely upon any portion of his testimony which is found to be credible and is supported by the circumstances and other reliable evidence of the case.
BD Law Post/Masum
