Pre-emption Can Be Claimed If a Deed of Exchange Is Proven to Be a Deed of Sale: High Court

Relevant Laws: Section 96 of the State Acquisition and Tenancy Act, 1950, and Section 115(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure.
The High Court has observed that a right of pre-emption may be exercised under the law where a transaction, although registered as a deed of exchange, is established to be a sale in substance. The Court further observed that where the applicant's status as a contiguous landholder is established and the deed has been conclusively determined to be a deed of sale, the right of pre-emption cannot be defeated merely by relying on the description of the instrument as a deed of exchange.

The observation came in a judgment delivered by a single bench of the High Court Division comprising Justice Md. Ali Reza in Abdul Mozid alias Mohammad Abdul Mozid alias Mujibur Rahman vs. Md. Abdul Matin (deceased), represented by his legal heirs Aleya Begum and others, Civil Revision No. 417 of 2022. The judgment was delivered on June 25, 2026.

Background of the Case

The petitioner was Abdul Mozid alias Mohammad Abdul Mozid alias Mujibur Rahman, while the opposite parties included Aleya Begum and others, the legal heirs of deceased Md. Abdul Matin.

The land under C.S. Plot No. 60 of Mouza Chaighoria, Shalikha Upazila, Magura, originally belonged to the petitioner and his brother through inheritance and purchase. Their homestead was situated on the said plot, adjacent to C.S. Plot No. 61.

According to the petitioner, 89 decimals of land under Plot No. 61 were contiguous to his homestead and were indispensable for convenient access to and from his residence.

On March 21, 1993, the said 89 decimals of land were transferred through registered Deed No. 1057. Although the deed was registered as a deed of exchange, the petitioner alleged that the transaction was, in substance, a sale. Claiming the status of a contiguous landholder, he sought pre-emption under Section 96 of the State Acquisition and Tenancy Act, 1950.

Suit to Establish the Deed as a Sale

To establish that the purported exchange transaction was actually a sale, the petitioner instituted Title Suit No. 46 of 1993.

Although the trial court initially dismissed the suit, the appellate court subsequently decreed Title Appeal No. 55 of 1994 in favour of the petitioner and declared the disputed instrument to be a deed of sale.

Challenging that decision, the purchaser filed Civil Revision No. 170 of 1995 before the High Court Division. On November 28, 2001, the High Court Division decided that the disputed instrument was, in fact, a deed of sale.

The judgment noted that the purported exchange transaction was merely colourable in nature and that there was specific evidence of payment of Tk. 50,000 as consideration. Accordingly, although the instrument had been registered as a deed of exchange, the actual transaction was a sale.

Decisions of the Lower Courts

On April 5, 1993, the petitioner instituted Miscellaneous Case No. 10 of 1993 under Section 96 of the State Acquisition and Tenancy Act, 1950, seeking pre-emption.

On January 14, 2018, the Assistant Judge, Shalikha, Magura, allowed the pre-emption case. The court observed that the disputed instrument had already been adjudicated as a deed of sale in a separate title suit, and that the decision had subsequently been affirmed by the High Court Division. Therefore, there was no legal impediment to allowing the claim for pre-emption.

Aggrieved by the decision, the purchaser filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 3 of 2018, while another party filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 4 of 2018.

On March 8, 2021, the Joint District Judge, 1st Court, Magura, dismissed both appeals and affirmed the decision of the trial court.

Thereafter, the matter was brought before the High Court Division through the present civil revision.

Observations of the High Court

The High Court Division observed that, by its earlier judgment dated November 28, 2001, the disputed instrument had been conclusively determined to be a deed of sale. That judgment had attained finality and was binding upon the parties. Consequently, the contention that the transaction was an exchange could no longer be raised in the subsequent pre-emption proceeding.

The Court further observed that the evidence established the petitioner as a contiguous landholder of the transferred property. During cross-examination, one of the witnesses for the opposite parties admitted that the petitioner's land was situated immediately to the west of the former Plot No. 61. This admission substantially established the petitioner's claim of contiguity.

Claim Regarding the Existence of a Road Not Established

The opposite parties contended that a road existed between Plot Nos. 60 and 61 and was used by local residents for ingress and egress.

However, they failed to produce reliable evidence in support of this contention. On the contrary, upon examining the C.S. and R.S. maps and the relevant R.S. record, the Court found that no road was shown between the two plots.

The witness for the opposite parties also failed to identify any map establishing the existence of such a road during cross-examination.

The Court concluded that the claim regarding the existence of a road had been advanced merely to defeat the petitioner's right of pre-emption and was not substantiated by reliable evidence.

Arguments Regarding Land Valuation and Development Costs

It was further argued that the actual value of the land exceeded the amount of Tk. 9,900 mentioned in the disputed deed. The purchaser also claimed to have spent Tk. 20,000 on the development of the land.

The High Court observed that the disputed deed itself specified the value of the transferred property as Tk. 9,900. Having executed and relied upon that instrument, the purchaser could not subsequently be permitted to claim a different valuation.

The Court also held that the alleged expenditure on land development did not materially affect the petitioner's entitlement to pre-emption in the circumstances of the case.

Final Decision of the High Court

Upon considering the submissions of the parties, oral and documentary evidence, and the judgments of the courts below, the High Court Division found that the lower courts had properly assessed the evidence and concurrently determined that the transaction was a sale, the petitioner was a contiguous landholder, and there was no legal impediment to granting pre-emption.

The Court found no misreading or non-consideration of material evidence, nor any misconception of law warranting interference under its revisional jurisdiction.

Accordingly, the Rule was discharged. The judgment and order dated March 8, 2021, passed by the Joint District Judge, 1st Court, Magura, in Miscellaneous Appeal Nos. 3 and 4 of 2018, affirming the decision of the trial court, were maintained and affirmed. The order of stay granted by the High Court Division was also vacated.

Source: Judgment of the High Court Division dated June 25, 2026, in Civil Revision No. 417 of 2022.

BD Law Post / Masum

Previous Post
No Comment
Add Comment
comment url