Court to Determine Payment Entitlement According to Contractual Terms: High Court
![]() |
| Mere Discharge of Cargo at Chattogram Port Does Not Entitle Carrier to the Remaining 20% Freight |
In a contractual dispute concerning the transportation of urea fertilizer, the Court held that merely completing the discharge of cargo at Chattogram Port did not create an entitlement to the remaining 20% of the agreed freight. The plaintiff was required to complete delivery to the designated BCIC godowns or factories and produce the documents stipulated under Clause 55(B) of the Charter Party Agreement.
The judgment was delivered by Justice Sikder Mahmudur Razi of the High Court Division on 9 September 2026 in Admiralty Suit No. 2 of 2023, filed by Dry Bulk Shipping (Pvt.) Ltd. against Bangladesh Chemical Industries Corporation (BCIC) and others. The suit was ultimately dismissed without any order as to costs.
Background of the Case:
BCIC invited Tender No. COMC-0100 dated 16 March 2022 for the transportation of urea fertilizer from Mesaieed Port, Qatar, to designated buffer godowns and factories in Bangladesh.
The tender contemplated two operational components. Part-A covered the international sea carriage of the cargo to Chattogram or Mongla Port, while Part-B covered local transportation from the discharge port to the designated BCIC godowns and factories.
Following acceptance of the bid, BCIC entered into a Charter Party Agreement dated 12 April 2022 with Dry Bulk Shipping (Pvt.) Ltd. for the carriage of the cargo.
The cargo, consisting of approximately 29,828.764 metric tonnes of urea, was transported by the vessel M.V. JIU FEING LING. After the cargo was discharged at Chattogram Port, the plaintiff claimed the unpaid balance of 20% of the agreed freight, along with demurrage, interest and other costs.
BCIC had already paid 80% of the agreed freight. The plaintiff claimed the remaining USD 438,661.80, contending that the balance became payable upon completion of the sea carriage and discharge of the cargo.
Defence Case:
The defendants contended that payment of the remaining 20% freight was subject to specific contractual conditions under Clause 55(B) of the Charter Party Agreement.
According to the defendants, the plaintiff was required to ensure delivery of the cargo to the designated BCIC godowns or factories and to submit the prescribed documents evidencing such delivery.
The defendants further contended that these contractual conditions had not been fulfilled and that the plaintiff failed to establish full delivery of the cargo to the designated destinations.
High Court's Observations:
The Court examined the tender documents and the Charter Party Agreement and found that the plaintiff's contractual responsibility did not end with the discharge of the cargo at Chattogram Port.
The Court observed that the contractual arrangement linked the release of the retained 20% freight to completion of delivery at the ultimate destinations and production of the required documents.
The plaintiff had completed the sea-carriage portion and was therefore entitled to the 80% freight already paid by BCIC. However, the entitlement to the remaining 20% was subject to a separate contractual condition—completion of delivery to the designated godowns or factories and production of the documents required under Clause 55(B).
The Court further observed that the plaintiff failed to prove that the entire cargo had been delivered to the designated destinations or that the required documents had been produced. Therefore, the retained 20% freight did not become payable merely because the cargo had been discharged at Chattogram Port.
The Court also clarified that liability for cargo loss and entitlement to the retained freight were two distinct issues. The plaintiff's failure to establish the contractual conditions for release of the retained freight was sufficient to defeat that part of the claim.
Key Legal Principle:
«Where a contract prescribes specific conditions for payment, the entitlement to such payment must be determined in accordance with the terms and conditions of the contract.»
In the present case, completion of discharge at Chattogram Port alone was insufficient. Full delivery to the designated BCIC godowns or factories and production of the documents required under Clause 55(B) were contractual conditions for payment of the remaining 20% freight.
Demurrage and Other Claims:
The Court further held that the claim for demurrage was excluded by Clause 51(II) of the contractual arrangement. The claims for bank interest and other incidental costs were also not independently established by legally sufficient evidence.
Although the plaintiff had completed the sea-carriage component, it had failed to ensure delivery at the ultimate destination points. The Court found that no corresponding contractual breach on the part of BCIC had been proved.
Final Decision:
The High Court answered the relevant issues against the plaintiff and held that the plaintiff was not entitled to the decree sought. Accordingly, Admiralty Suit No. 2 of 2023 was dismissed without any order as to costs.
Source: Judgment in Admiralty Suit No. 2 of 2023.
BD Law Post/Masum
